Talk: Featured article

Template:Archives1

Current nominations

Nominate below! User:Kirkburn/Sig2 17:33, 28 March 2007 (EDT)

Illidan Stormrage

• Oppose, for now. I've tried to work out some weird stuff but the article is not there yet. First off, this article isn't very well referenced; I see multiple instances of {{fact}}. Furthermore, I'd like to know who styled him "Lord Illidan". APΘLLΘ^(ZEUS) 02:17, 29 March 2007 (EDT)
• Support, it's had a fair few changes since the above, and I've spent some time improving the article today. User:Kirkburn/Sig3 14:53, 18 April 2007 (EDT)
• Support, This artile was the first to pop up in my mind even before i entered WW:FA  D ♠ T ♣ C ♦  15:26, 18 April 2007 (EDT)
• Support, You are not prepared! <- Still gives me chills. Silly reason I know. I did read the article and it is interesting. User:Kitan/Sig 15:37, 18 April 2007 (EDT)

Classes & Races

I think we should have classes in there, just a a bit of help, and races for a bit of lore. I am not very good at making suggestions, but there is my idea. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by Shigamori (talk · contr).

I've looked at your suggestion and have viewed every class and race page separately. Here's my report:

The druid article is good

The hunter article is badly lined out

The mage article is short, and the section weren't done good enough

Paladin, I dislike that black table, and an article with a cleanup template can not become featured until its prose is reworked

Priest; this article has a redundant quest section, and it doesn't have external links

Rogue, also no no external links section, and the title isn't bold

Shaman, *gasp* no pictures of totems?, also, the section headers were poorly done

Warlock, the section 'Macros' needs to go, and an external links section needs to be created

Warrior, too short

Human, nice

Dwarf, rather short

Night elf, nice

Gnome, the big quote is unprofessional, and the section names aren't logical

Draenei, section "Controversy, confusion, and retcons" has gotta go

Orc, no WoW screenshots

Undead, "Opinion and analysis" should be removed

Tauren, nice

Troll, nice

Blood elf, get rid of "Dark Destiny" and "Controversy"

I hope that helps. APΘLLΘ^(ZEUS) 04:36, 9 April 2007 (EDT)

I'll look at those and try to make them good enough to feature Shigamori (talk · contr)

Previous nominations

Garona Halforcen

• Support. I just edited the page to work out some minor style issues, and I personally think this article is really complete now. APΘLLΘ^(ZEUS) 02:17, 29 March 2007 (EDT)

This article has now been featured User:Kirkburn/Sig3 14:53, 18 April 2007 (EDT)