- Player housing is not theoretical since the implementation of Garrisons with the Warlords of Draenor expansion. However. guild housing still remains theoretical.
Player housing (PH), or Guild housing (GH), are theoretical features that would give players a place to store items and have a place to call home. Introducing housing into the game could have many primary and secondary effects.
Potential types of guild housing
Reasons for guild housing
- Guilds need a common meeting place. Guild Halls would be perfect
- Guilds need help fostering a sense of cohesiveness and loyalty, providing player housing within a guild-based, instanced housing community would do that.
- Housing provides the developers with an excellent opportunity to add to the professions.
- Guild vs Guild PVP has been in demand, GH provides an opportunity to implement that.
- Guild Housing can become an important recruiting tool, as one-day passes could be crafted.
Reason to not add guild housing
- Allowing guilds to congregate inside guild-only instanced areas will remove those guilded players from the major cities. The end result could turn the major cities into Ghost towns.
- If GH was implemented in a way that the city's services are duplicated inside the instanced GH area, guilded players will have another incentive not to leave their specialized area.
- The developer hours and resourced dedication aren't worth the reward/detriment that GH causes.
Potential types of player housing
- Main article: Garrison
- Common building or room with a private (maybe expandable) storage area similar to a bank.
- Instanced building or room that allows a player to enter their "house".
- ...and party members or guild members.
- Separate building or room with a "lockable" door that only the player has a "key" to, but other players can enter when the door is open.
- Private area (instanced or not) that allows "furnishing".
- A soulbound item similar to a Hearthstone that transports you to your house.
The player-driven debate
Throughout the years, the players have discussed and debated how the features of Player Housing (PH) or Guild Housing (GH) could be implemented within WoW. Most are in agreement that the Housing feature will inevitably make it into the game. Here are the arguments:
Reasons to add housing for players
- While banks are good for storing the things you don't need right now, a demand for displaying the accrued equipment or special items has not been addressed directly.
- Players have requested gear racks so that a complete armor set could be displayed properly.
- A players house could help remove the clutter of one's inventory, provide a meeting space that friends can visit, and increase the in-game feel of WoW.
- It would be ideal for roleplaying and taking care of your house would add a whole new dimension to the game.
- In case of another Corrupted Blood Incident or a similar disease, players could stay in their homes and wait for the disease to go away, and would be safe in their private house.
Reasons to not add player housing
- The development costs and added storage requirements for player housing could be detrimental to the continuous demand of developer's time and the infrastructure's resources.
- Player-based housing only creates more management and frustration. Players already forget important items and gear in the bank. Adding PH will force them to remember where they stored the items (though a "Warehouse" addon, similar to the one Carbonite provides, could help to fix some of the confusion)
- Adding storage space within a house duplicates city-based services (the bank)
- The lore implications of the background of the character changes from its current background as a nomadic hero.
Housing's effect on professions
The advent of Player and/or guild housing in WoW, provides the developers an opportunity to add new professions and augment the current professions with more recipes. The mechanism for acquiring housing could be a mass resource turn in. Implementing housing in this way will promote the crafting economy as the resource gathering will have to be repeated for new and rerolled characters or if you want to change your house-style.
Every profession can be augmented. Here's a list of new items that could be added:
- Large potion powders to apply to communal fountains
- Special scents for decorative smoke
- Coat-of-Arm pieces (armor assembled to look like stationary guards)
- Cannon casings
- Spikes, hinges, other door pieces.
- Beer Mugs
- Furniture (eg: tables/chairs barring the potential addition of Carpentry as a profession)
- enchants for stationary objects.
- portkeys to take you from one end to another
- levitating furniture and animated objects that would be otherwise stationary
- Robot guards
- motion sensors, behavior components, arms, legs, chest, head
- arrow shooters
- door locks
- Books (for display on shelves)
- Paint for wall colorings
- Crown Jewels, Throne jewels, jeweled cups
- Rugs, Canvas, and rope
- Tanned Banners
- Banners and Flags
- tablecloth, runners, chair decorations
- specialized guild-only garments for cloth wearers
Pre-Warlords statusWhile there are models and spells in the game files related to player housing, these are more likely from the alpha version of World of Warcraft but never made it live.
During the Gamescom 2010, Tom Chilton declared that "housing will be introduced to World of Warcraft some time right after "never"."
Caydiem: "Housing is a huge feature with a lot of dedicated time needed. While we definitely want to do housing, and it is something 'on the list', it's not a 'soon after release' feature. It's more of an 'on the horizon' feature. :)"
Katricia: "Guild Halls will most likely not be implemented before World of Warcraft is released. They are very similar to Player Housing (which also will not make the release).
Both Player Housing and Guild Halls will be implemented as soon as possible after release.
I have no information available regarding the functions of either Guild Halls or Player Housing.
Katricia: Player housing will not be available until after World of Warcraft has been released. Our plan is to add player housing in a future live update or expansion. Our current idea (which could change) is to extend the cities to have player housing neighborhoods. For example, in the canal area of Stormwind players can see a blue instance portal behind a large portcullis; this is the entrance to the player housing neighborhood in Stormwind.
Tigole: " You've posted some really cool ideas on Guild Halls.
Player and guild housing is something we've always been interested in pursuing. While we won't be including those features in the Burning Crusade, that doesn't mean we've abandoned our hope to include housing in the game sometime in the future."
Nethaera: "The word is that we like the idea of player housing and would like to implement it at some point in the future, however we don't have any particular ETA of when we will. There is a laundry list of things we still would like to add to World of Warcraft and this is just one of them."
Nethaera: "These were not promised at any particular time . I don't believe we even used the word "promise" in any statements about these. We have said in the past , however, that these are things we would like to see added to the game. I can't give you an ETA since we don't have one as of yet.
We'd like them added in, sure, but beyond that we couldn't tell you more. When we get close to a point where we actually are implementing these things, we'll do what we can to give you all a heads-up."
Drysc: "Heh, well skimming through it seems not everyone wants player housing at the moment. Not that we use the forums as a barometer for popular opinion, but anyway...Player housing is still something that intrigues us. If the place and time are right, and we can add player housing and make it a meaningful addition to the game, make it cool, we'll do so."
Tom Chilton: "Is there a feature in another MMO that you admire and would like to see in WoW? Sure! Right now, for example, we don't have a housing system. Other MMOs have it and it's a system that we've talked about since before the launch of the original WoW. We've talked about housing and how we'd do it and how it might work for at least five years.
Is it something you're actively working on?
No, we're not working on right now, but it's incredibly complex to do right and we're not sure yet if it's going to be the right thing for WoW in the long run. It has major implications for the game itself and again I wouldn't go out of my way and say never but it's not on the immediately of things to do."
- β News